Topic introduction: AFGHANISTAN INQUIRY

The Independent Inquiry relating to Afghanistan, chaired by Lord Justice Sir Charles Haddon-Cave, was established by the then Conservative government on 15 December 2022 to examine allegations that British Special Air Service (SAS) units carried out unlawful extrajudicial killings of Afghan civilians and detainees during "night raids" between 2010 and 2013, alongside claims of institutional cover-up.

According to reported evidence to the inquiry, members of three SAS groups are accused of summarily killing roughly 80 people during these operations.

Whatever may be the truth of any of the allegations and what (if any) further action should be taken, it is obvious from social media and reader comments that there are common misunderstandings amongst members of the public.

We therefore summarise our understanding of the allegations below, without endorsing any particular versions of the facts, the law, or how these matters should be handled as a metter of national policy. We are open to any corrections to this summary based on the actual Inquiry evidence or statements.

Allegations of Unlawful Killings

Summary Executions of Detainees. Troops allegedly captured unarmed Afghan men during compound searches, separated them from their families, and led them back inside buildings ostensibly to assist with secondary searches, before shooting them.

Fabricated Self-Defence Claims. It is alleged that soldiers repeatedly used nearly identical official justifications for the shootings, claiming the detainees had suddenly produced hidden pistols or grenades from behind curtains or mattresses. Reports indicate no SAS troopers were ever injured in these supposed attacks.

Killings in Beds and Civilian Casualties. Specific alleged incidents under scrutiny include a February 2011 raid in the Nad Ali district where nine unarmed people were allegedly shot in their beds, as well as a 2012 raid in Nimruz province where parents were killed and two toddlers were shot while sleeping.

Body Count Rivalries. Evidence presented to the inquiry suggests different SAS squadrons competed over the number of people killed during deployments, with soldiers allegedly joking over email about "the latest massacre" and the implausibility of their official reports.

Refusal by Partner Forces. Partnering Afghan special forces eventually refused to accompany certain UK units on raids because they did not want to participate in what they viewed as assassination squads.

Flawed Military Police Probes. The inquiry is investigating why earlier Royal Military Police investigations – specifically Operations Northmoor and Cestro – closed without bringing a single charge despite allegedly significant evidence.

Withheld Evidence and Silence. The inquiry has uncovered tens of millions of previously unexamined Ministry of Defence records and thousands of photographs. Meanwhile, Lord Justice Haddon-Cave noted in October 2026 that most SAS personnel directly implicated in the raids have refused to answer questions, citing privileges against self-incrimination.

In November 2026 The Times reported a warning by the President of the SAS Association that personnel could be at risk from hostile state actors using artificial intelligence to "join the dots" in order to identify them from Afghan Inquiry evidence; that the regiment believed the MoD and the inquiry were not giving proper attention to such threats; and that if troops were concerned, they should stay “silent” and stop co-operating with the inquiry.

Statements by Afghanistan Inquiry Chairman

Sir Charles Haddon-Cave, the chair of the Independent Inquiry relating to Afghanistan, has explicitly stated that the investigation is not about "split-second decisions taken in the heat of combat" or the "fog of war." Instead, he has emphasised that the inquiry focuses on whether UK Special Forces carried out a deliberate practice of unlawful killings during operations between mid-2010 and mid-2013.

Whether a deliberate, planned, routine practice

During open hearings in September and October 2026, Haddon-Cave clarified the exact scope of the allegations. He stated that the inquiry is investigating whether the SAS engaged in a routine practice of executing unarmed civilians and detainees – specifically "males of a fighting age" – during night-time Deliberate Detention Operations.

Internal Military Whistleblowers

Haddon-Cave has repeatedly reminded the public that these allegations did not simply come from external critics. He stressed that the claims of unlawful killings and falsified operational reports originated from within UK Special Forces personnel themselves.

Clearing the Innocent and Prosecuting Offenders

When launching the inquiry, Haddon-Cave emphasized that the allegations remain unproven at this stage. He stated that it is vital to ensure anyone who broke the law is referred to the relevant authorities, while lifting the cloud of suspicion from the vast majority of soldiers who acted lawfully.

The inquiry continues, with Haddon-Cave setting an April 2027 deadline for the Ministry of Defence to finish disclosing relevant historical files.

 

Further reading

 
 

If you don't see what you were looking for, or if there are no current blog posts with the topic you selected, to include earlier articles you can try a Site Search.

Is there some topic which BAFF should be reporting or commenting on? If so please use the contact form to let us know.